How to identify this issue
- The stroke has the right width and the right position, and only the colour is wrong.
- The wrong colour is black, or a duller version of a saturated colour.
- The swatch was set from a picker other than RGB, a Lab or spot colour book among them, or the document colour mode is not RGB.
Solution
1
Reset the swatch from the RGB picker.
Open Layer > Layer Style > Stroke, click the colour swatch, and switch
the picker to RGB before choosing the colour again. Photoshop keeps the mode
you used last, so this is worth checking on every effect in the file rather
than only the one you noticed.
2
Convert the document to RGB.
Other colour modes render as their RGB equivalent, and converting in
Photoshop while you still hold the ink values leaves the decision with you.
Preparing a PSD carries the rest of the file
requirements.
3
Upload the file again.
A template registered a while ago keeps the effect colours it had when you
uploaded it, so a correction reaches your renders only through a new upload.
The new template carries its own UUID.
4
Render at the template's own width and compare.
Export the same file from Photoshop at the same width and set the two side
by side, rather than judging the render against the Layers panel.